Roomful Mystery.

Roomful Games › Mystery › The Case of the Missing Pie

Family Mystery Party: The Case of the Missing Pie

Grandma's pumpkin pie was cooling on the windowsill at 4:00, and at 4:15 it was gone. Each player gets a secret character and private clues, and after three rounds everyone votes on who moved the pie, and why.

Roomful Mystery on a TV, with a phone showing the same game

Play this on your TV

Play this on your TV

Print the free party kit

Print the free party kit

The story

Welcome to Grandma's house for the big family dinner! Dinner is over, the plates are stacked, and everyone is full and happy. Grandma's famous pumpkin pie has been cooling on a rack on the kitchen windowsill since 2:30. At 4:00, Alex took a picture of it. At 4:15, Grandma went to get it for dessert, and the rack was empty! A pie can't walk away by itself. Somebody at this dinner knows where it went. Let's find out who, and why.

The invitation

Grandma's pumpkin pie has gone missing! Come to dinner, play a part, and help us solve The Case of the Missing Pie.

The cast

  • Alex the Photographer

    Takes pictures of everything. Every picture on Alex's camera shows the time it was taken.

    Costume idea: A pretend camera on a strap around your neck (a small box works great).

  • Casey the Crafter

    Loves paper, paint and tape. Spent the afternoon making a thank-you table on the back porch.

    Costume idea: A paint-smudged apron or old shirt, and a paper leaf pinned to your collar.

  • Jamie the Puzzle Fan

    Has been doing a big jigsaw puzzle with Grandma all afternoon. It's a picture of a pumpkin patch.

    Costume idea: A puzzle piece pinned to your shirt, or a hat with puzzle pieces drawn on it.

  • Jordan the Helper

    Grandma's best helper. Clears plates, carries leftovers and always says, "Sure, I can do that!"

    Costume idea: A dish towel over your shoulder and rolled-up sleeves.

  • Morgan the Musician

    Brought a guitar to dinner and played on the back porch while Casey made the thank-you table.

    Costume idea: A pretend guitar (a broom or a cardboard cutout works) and a music note sticker.

  • Pat the Neighbor

    Lives next door and comes over every year. Brought a big bowl of whipped cream for the pie.

    Costume idea: A big mixing bowl and a spoon, or a fluffy white scarf like whipped cream.

  • Quinn the Table Setter

    Set the dining room table for dessert, with plates, forks and napkins folded into fancy shapes.

    Costume idea: A napkin folded over your arm, or a fork and spoon tucked in a pocket.

  • Riley the Dog Walker

    Takes care of Grandma's dog, Biscuit. Always has dog treats in a pocket and a leash close by.

    Costume idea: A leash over your shoulder and a pocket full of pretend dog treats.

Hosting it at Thanksgiving

The story happens at a big family dinner, between the main course and dessert, so it fits the same gap at your own table: play while the real pie cools.

Grandma is in the story, not in the cast, so nobody has to play her. Send the invitations a week ahead with each guest's character, and let people plan the costume idea on their card. With more than eight at the table, the extra guests play detectives.

How to play

For 3 to 12 players, about 40 minutes, ages 8 and up. The how-to-host page has every step.

More to play