Roomful Mystery.

Roomful Games › Mystery › The Christmas Cookie Caper

Christmas Mystery Party: The Christmas Cookie Caper

The prize cookie tray has vanished from the neighborhood bake-off, ten minutes before the judging! Everyone gets a secret character and clues, and the whole room works out who moved it.

Roomful Mystery on a TV, with a phone showing the same game

Play this on your TV

Play this on your TV

Print the free party kit

Print the free party kit

The story

Welcome to the Maple Street Clubhouse for the neighborhood holiday bake-off! Lights twinkle, carolers sing on the porch, and the hall smells like gingerbread. At 2:00, Sam the Baker set the big silver prize tray on the long table by the fireplace. It holds the best cookie from every baker, ready for the judging at 3:00. But at 2:50, just ten minutes before the judging, the prize tray is gone! Who moved it, and why?

The invitation

You're invited to The Christmas Cookie Caper! Come to our bake-off mystery party, help find the missing prize cookie tray, and enjoy some cookies too.

The cast

  • Alex the Caroler

    Alex leads the carols on the porch and has a big, happy voice.

    Costume idea: A scarf, mittens, and a songbook.

  • Casey the Decorator

    Casey hangs lights on anything that stands still.

    Costume idea: A paper chain of lights around your neck, and a tool belt.

  • Jordan the Host

    Jordan runs the bake-off and loves twinkle lights more than anything.

    Costume idea: A sweater with lights on it, and a little bell to ring.

  • Morgan the Dog Walker

    Morgan brought Biscuit, a friendly dog in a red sweater.

    Costume idea: A leash, and a toy dog if you have one.

  • Pat the Judge

    Pat is this year's cookie judge and takes the job very seriously.

    Costume idea: A clipboard, a pencil, and a fancy scarf or bow tie.

  • Riley the Helper

    Riley helps at every party: pouring cocoa, passing napkins, and doing every job on their list.

    Costume idea: A helper badge and a mug for cocoa.

  • Robin the Photographer

    Robin takes a picture of everything, about once a minute.

    Costume idea: A toy camera on a strap.

  • Sam the Baker

    Sam bakes snowflake cookies with a chocolate drizzle, and set up the prize tray.

    Costume idea: An apron with a little flour on it, and an oven mitt.

Hosting it at a holiday party

The Christmas Cookie Caper is set at a neighborhood bake-off, so it suits a holiday party with cookies on the table. Ask each guest to bring a batch, and judge the real cookies after the big reveal.

With mixed ages, pair a younger child with a grown-up on one character, and let the child read their clues aloud. The story has carolers, a judge and a decorator, so a costume can be as simple as a scarf, a clipboard or a roll of ribbon.

How to play

For 3 to 12 players, about 40 minutes, ages 8 and up. The how-to-host page has every step.

More to play